Court of Appeal Quashes Land Commission Ruling Against Eastern Produce in Nandi

Kenya’s Court of Appeal on Friday threw out a land commission ruling that would have stripped tea grower Eastern Produce Kenya Ltd of a property in Nandi County, saying the company was never shown the evidence against it.
The National Land Commission, the state body that investigates claims of historical land injustice, had in 2019 sided with a local farmers’ group, Kimasas Farmers’ Co-operative Society. It recommended that the titles carved out of a parcel known as L.R. No. 9285 be cancelled and the land handed to the society. Eastern Produce holds the title to one of those plots and says it has tea factories and tea bushes on it.
Three appeal judges said the commission reached that decision unfairly. The company’s lawyer twice asked for the documents the farmers were relying on, and the commission promised to supply them. It then decided the case without doing so and held the company’s silence against it.
A party “cannot reasonably be expected to answer allegations founded upon documents” it has never seen and has expressly asked for, Justices L. Kimaru, L. Njuguna and J.O. Okello said in a joint judgment.
The ruling is a significant win for Eastern Produce, but it does not settle who should own the land. The judges said they were ruling only on how the commission handled the case, not on whether the farmers’ claim is valid. That question, they said, is for the commission to consider at a properly conducted hearing. They made no order on whether or when a fresh hearing should be held.
A claim reaching back to colonial times
The society lodged its complaint in February 2018. It said its members’ forefathers lived on and farmed the land before colonial settlers took it over and turned them into squatters.
It said that in 1986 a manager at the tea company, P.G. Scott, agreed to settle its members on about 550 acres. Only about 210 acres were transferred, after the society paid roughly 247,000 shillings, and the other 340 acres were held back, it said.
The society also alleged that part of the land was secretly acquired by Henry Kosgey, a former member of parliament for Tinderet, and his associates. The appeal court made no finding on that allegation, and Kosgey was not a party to the case.
Eastern Produce told the courts it is the registered owner of one of the plots, L.R. No. 9285/3, under a government grant issued in May 1999. It said carrying out the commission’s recommendation would cost it the property and its investments there.
Twenty-one days, no documents
The commission called the company to sessions in Nandi on July 10 and 11, 2018. The company’s lawyer attended and said he had not received the papers behind the complaint, so could not answer it properly.
The commission gave the company 21 days to reply in writing and said its secretariat would provide the documents. Eastern Produce said the papers never came and no further hearing was called.
The commission issued its decision on Feb. 7, 2019, noting that the company had not replied, and published it in the government gazette on March 1.
In court, the commission and the society argued that the company had been given a hearing and a deadline, and had only itself to blame for not using them. The Environment and Land Court agreed in April 2023, when Justice Angote dismissed the company’s challenge.
Why the appeal court disagreed
The appeal judges accepted that a body like the commission does not have to run a full court-style trial. But they said it must still give anyone whose rights are at stake a real chance to know the case against them and answer it.
Fairness, they said, “is not reduced to a formal invitation to appear”.
They drew a line between two kinds of party. One has everything it needs and chooses to stay silent. The other tells the decision-maker it lacks the documents and is assured they are coming.
Eastern Produce was in the second group, the judges said. Its failure to reply could therefore not be treated as giving up its right to be heard, and a 21-day deadline meant little without the material needed to meet it.
Because the case turned on fairness, the court did not decide the company’s other arguments. Eastern Produce had said the dispute was about an unfinished gift of land between private parties, not a historical injustice. It also said the claim was filed too late, and that the commission had no valid rules to work under after parliament annulled its regulations in March 2018.
The orders
The court set aside the 2023 judgment and quashed the commission’s decision and gazette notice as far as they concern Eastern Produce and L.R. No. 9285. It ordered the commission and the society to pay the company’s costs of the appeal.
The society opposed the appeal. The commission, the Chief Land Registrar and the Nandi County government, all named in the case, did not take part in it.
Read Also: Fraudulent Tatu City Ownership Claim Quashed by UK’s Final Court Of Appeal
About Soko Directory Team
Soko Directory is a Financial and Markets digital portal that tracks brands, listed firms on the NSE, SMEs and trend setters in the markets eco-system.Find us on Facebook: facebook.com/SokoDirectory and on Twitter: twitter.com/SokoDirectory
- January 2026 (220)
- February 2026 (248)
- March 2026 (287)
- April 2026 (207)
- May 2026 (193)
- June 2026 (240)
- July 2026 (283)
- August 2026 (226)
- September 2026 (261)
- October 2026 (253)
- November 2026 (269)
- January 2025 (119)
- February 2025 (191)
- March 2025 (212)
- April 2025 (193)
- May 2025 (161)
- June 2025 (157)
- July 2025 (227)
- August 2025 (211)
- September 2025 (267)
- October 2025 (297)
- November 2025 (230)
- December 2025 (220)
- January 2024 (238)
- February 2024 (227)
- March 2024 (190)
- April 2024 (133)
- May 2024 (157)
- June 2024 (145)
- July 2024 (136)
- August 2024 (154)
- September 2024 (212)
- October 2024 (255)
- November 2024 (196)
- December 2024 (143)
- January 2023 (182)
- February 2023 (203)
- March 2023 (322)
- April 2023 (297)
- May 2023 (267)
- June 2023 (214)
- July 2023 (212)
- August 2023 (257)
- September 2023 (237)
- October 2023 (264)
- November 2023 (286)
- December 2023 (177)
- January 2022 (293)
- February 2022 (329)
- March 2022 (358)
- April 2022 (292)
- May 2022 (271)
- June 2022 (232)
- July 2022 (278)
- August 2022 (253)
- September 2022 (246)
- October 2022 (196)
- November 2022 (232)
- December 2022 (167)
- January 2021 (182)
- February 2021 (227)
- March 2021 (325)
- April 2021 (259)
- May 2021 (285)
- June 2021 (272)
- July 2021 (277)
- August 2021 (232)
- September 2021 (271)
- October 2021 (303)
- November 2021 (364)
- December 2021 (249)
- January 2020 (272)
- February 2020 (310)
- March 2020 (390)
- April 2020 (321)
- May 2020 (335)
- June 2020 (327)
- July 2020 (333)
- August 2020 (276)
- September 2020 (214)
- October 2020 (233)
- November 2020 (242)
- December 2020 (187)
- January 2019 (251)
- February 2019 (215)
- March 2019 (283)
- April 2019 (254)
- May 2019 (269)
- June 2019 (249)
- July 2019 (335)
- August 2019 (292)
- September 2019 (306)
- October 2019 (313)
- November 2019 (362)
- December 2019 (318)
- January 2018 (291)
- February 2018 (213)
- March 2018 (275)
- April 2018 (223)
- May 2018 (235)
- June 2018 (176)
- July 2018 (256)
- August 2018 (247)
- September 2018 (255)
- October 2018 (282)
- November 2018 (282)
- December 2018 (184)
- January 2017 (183)
- February 2017 (194)
- March 2017 (207)
- April 2017 (104)
- May 2017 (169)
- June 2017 (205)
- July 2017 (189)
- August 2017 (195)
- September 2017 (186)
- October 2017 (235)
- November 2017 (253)
- December 2017 (266)
- January 2016 (164)
- February 2016 (165)
- March 2016 (189)
- April 2016 (143)
- May 2016 (245)
- June 2016 (182)
- July 2016 (271)
- August 2016 (247)
- September 2016 (233)
- October 2016 (191)
- November 2016 (243)
- December 2016 (153)
- January 2015 (1)
- February 2015 (4)
- March 2015 (164)
- April 2015 (107)
- May 2015 (116)
- June 2015 (119)
- July 2015 (145)
- August 2015 (157)
- September 2015 (186)
- October 2015 (169)
- November 2015 (173)
- December 2015 (205)
- March 2014 (2)
- March 2013 (10)
- June 2013 (1)
- March 2012 (7)
- April 2012 (15)
- May 2012 (1)
- July 2012 (1)
- August 2012 (4)
- October 2012 (2)
- November 2012 (2)
- December 2012 (1)
