When the State Balances Its Budget on a Supplier’s Back

A government can appear to restrain spending while transferring the cost of its commitments to businesses that have already delivered. The road has been repaired, the hospital supplied, or the school furnished. The public receives the service. The contractor receives a promise. Until settlement, the state’s apparent saving is financed by someone else’s overdraft, supplier credit or household reserves. Fiscal restraint measured only by cash leaving the treasury can therefore conceal a private-sector financing operation conducted without consent.
This is the distinctive danger of public payment arrears. An ordinary commercial debtor may lose customers when its reputation deteriorates. A public authority retains statutory powers, political importance and often an unmatched position in local demand. Small suppliers may continue bidding because alternative markets are thin. The state can remain an indispensable customer even after becoming an unreliable payer, leaving entrepreneurs to choose between revenue concentration and insufficient revenue at all.
A 2014 technical note by Suzanne Flynn and Mario Pessoa, published by the IMF, defines government expenditure arrears around obligations that have fallen due but remain unpaid. It identifies weaknesses across budgeting, commitment controls, verification and cash management as possible causes. The document is technical guidance by its authors, rather than a statement of the IMF Executive Board’s views. Its enduring analytical contribution is to treat arrears as a public financial management failure with identifiable stages, rather than an accounting inconvenience.
Precision matters because not every submitted bill is a verified debt. Fraudulent claims, duplicate invoices, disputed quantities and unauthorised commitments exist. Governments must protect public money. But uncertainty about some claims cannot justify treating every supplier as an indefinitely patient investigator of the state’s own records. An arrears register should distinguish amounts submitted, amounts under dispute, verified obligations and approved payments awaiting cash. Combining these categories invites both exaggerated claims and evasive official explanations.
The economic damage begins before a supplier formally defaults. A delayed payment consumes borrowing capacity that might otherwise fund a new commercial contract. The owner may reject an order from a reliable private customer because the state already occupies the company’s financing limit. That lost sale will not appear on the public arrears register. Nor will the worker who was never hired or the machine that remained on a quotation rather than entering production.
Arrears also contaminate credit assessment. A lender observing missed instalments may downgrade the business even when the original liquidity shock came from a public debtor. The supplier’s future cost of funds rises, and the state pays no corresponding premium for having caused the deterioration. Without careful analysis of receivables quality and the debtor’s payment process, a banking system can mistake exposure to government dysfunction for evidence of an entrepreneur’s intrinsic unreliability.
An illustrative contract shows the asymmetry. Suppose a firm completes an assignment costing Sh8 million against a Sh10 million price. If it finances the Sh8 million cash cost for an unplanned additional year at 16 per cent simple interest, the extra financing charge is Sh1.28 million. Before overheads, tax and any other project costs, a Sh2 million spread has fallen to Sh720,000. These invented figures are a sensitivity example, not a claim about Kenyan procurement margins or prevailing loan terms.
The obvious response is to price in delay, but that creates another fiscal problem. Suppliers expecting unreliable settlement demand more to compensate for financing and risk. Those unwilling or unable to price uncertainty may withdraw. Competition then narrows to firms with stronger balance sheets, unusually cheap funding, or relationships that appear to improve payment prospects. The public buyer may receive fewer serious bids and worse value even before any corrupt transaction occurs.
When payment becomes discretionary, a further danger emerges: settlement itself becomes a scarce benefit. A supplier may feel pressure to cultivate intermediaries or accept an unexplained discount to move forward in the queue. This is a risk inherent in opaque processes, not an allegation against any named office or individual. Publishing objective settlement criteria reduces the room for such pressure. Suppliers should not need privileged access to discover whether an undisputed obligation will be honoured.
An arrears clearance programme must therefore answer more than how much money will be released. It must explain who qualifies, how claims are validated, what order governs settlement and how disputes are appealed. Paying the most politically connected or most vocal claimants first can punish suppliers that followed the rules. A transparent framework may consider age, legal status and vulnerability, but the criteria should be stated before individual cases are chosen.
Securitising arrears or offering settlement instruments can provide relief, although the accounting deserves close inspection. A tradable claim may allow a supplier to obtain cash sooner by selling at a discount. That discount is an economic loss unless someone compensates the seller. Replacing a cash obligation with a less liquid instrument does not eliminate the underlying cost. It changes who holds the claim, who bears valuation risk, and how visibly the burden appears in public accounts.
Prevention requires control at the moment of commitment. An agency should not place orders simply because a budget line exists if the cash plan cannot support the resulting payment schedule. Multi-year projects need credible financing arrangements across their full duration. Otherwise, officials can announce new commitments while old obligations wait. Restricting the creation of fresh arrears may be less politically attractive than launching another clearance exercise, but it is the difference between repairing a system and periodically emptying its overflow.