The One Choice That Undermine Your Finance: What The Right Sacco Can To For You, And What The Wrong One Can Cost

When it comes to choosing a SACCO (Savings and Credit Cooperative), many Kenyan investors fall into a trap of focusing solely on the dividend returns or rebates, without considering the broader financial health and sustainability of the institution. While the allure of high dividends may seem like the perfect way to boost savings, the truth is that overlooking a SACCO’s financial stability and regulatory compliance can cost you dearly. In fact, it could mean losing all your hard-earned money.

Kenya’s SACCO sector, with its 176 licensed deposit-taking SACCOs, has seen significant growth over the years, driven by the demand for accessible credit and investment options. The appeal is evident—members can save, borrow, and earn competitive returns. However, not all SACCOs are created equal, and the ease of entry might disguise deeper financial vulnerabilities that can jeopardize your savings. The first step in avoiding this risk is understanding the basic financial health of a SACCO.

The Sacco Societies Regulatory Authority (SASRA) sets strict guidelines to ensure that SACCOs remain solvent and meet financial obligations. These include ratios such as the core capital to total assets ratio, which should be no less than 10%, and the core capital to total deposits ratio, which should exceed 8%. These are essential for maintaining a SACCO’s liquidity and protecting member deposits. However, it’s crucial to recognize that meeting these minimum regulatory requirements does not necessarily guarantee profitability or security. SACCOs that scrape by with the bare minimum might still fail to provide consistent returns or, worse, face insolvency in the face of financial shocks.

Read Also: Kenyan MPs: The Greatest Threat To Sacco Stability And The Nation’s Economic Future

In addition to financial ratios, ensuring that a SACCO is licensed and regularly monitored by SASRA is vital. Regulatory compliance is the bedrock of stability in the SACCO environment. A SACCO’s commitment to adhering to these standards means it is subject to audits and checks, which minimizes the risk of financial mismanagement or fraudulent activities. Yet, even within the regulated SACCOs, there are some that manage to operate under a thin veneer of compliance while masking deeper issues—issues like inefficient management, inadequate loan loss provisions, or even outright corruption.

This brings us to the next crucial factor: management and governance. SACCOs are fundamentally member-driven, which means that the competency and accountability of the board and executive management are paramount. A SACCO with a strong, ethical management team is far more likely to navigate economic downturns and ensure the long-term security of members’ funds. As a potential investor, you must assess the qualifications and track record of the leadership. Are they transparent about their decision-making? Do they have a history of acting in the best interests of their members? If the answers to these questions are unclear, you might be better off taking your business elsewhere.

Of course, one of the key motivators for joining a SACCO is the promise of returns. Many SACCOs entice potential members with high dividend rates on shares and attractive interest rates on savings. While this can be tempting, it’s important to take a critical view of these offers. High returns often come with high risks, and SACCOs that promise unreasonably high dividends might be overleveraged, operating with low reserves, or engaging in risky lending practices. Sustainable returns are more likely from SACCOs with solid capital buffers, disciplined lending policies, and a diverse portfolio of investments. In fact, the true measure of a SACCO’s health isn’t just the size of its dividends but how it balances profitability with the need to preserve capital for future growth and member protection.

Another consideration that many people fail to weigh heavily enough is the availability of loan products and the terms attached to them. SACCOs are, after all, designed not just for savings, but for credit access. A SACCO’s loan products should cater to the diverse needs of its members, with clear terms, reasonable interest rates, and realistic repayment schedules. In some cases, SACCOs may offer loans at attractive interest rates, but with steep eligibility requirements or punitive penalties for late payments. It is crucial to evaluate these terms and ensure they align with your personal or business needs. Look for SACCOs that offer flexibility in terms of loan amount, repayment period, and interest rates without hidden charges.

Read Also: Why Banks Should Fear And Why Every Entrepreneur Needs A Sacco Account

The issue of access is equally important. While SACCOs are supposed to provide convenient access to services, some still operate with limited branch networks or lack robust online platforms. In a fast-paced, digital world, the ability to access your funds and manage your account remotely is not just a convenience—it’s a necessity. You should evaluate whether a SACCO’s technological offerings meet your expectations for speed, reliability, and security. For those who live or work far from SACCO branches, online banking options or mobile apps become essential for managing accounts and transferring funds quickly.

Equally important is understanding the SACCO’s membership eligibility criteria. While some SACCOs cater to specific sectors, like teachers, doctors, or farmers, others may have broader membership requirements. Each SACCO has its own set of rules regarding who can join, often influenced by the industry it serves. Be sure to assess these criteria carefully, ensuring that you meet all requirements before committing. Furthermore, many SACCOs charge initial registration fees or require members to purchase shares to gain full membership. These financial commitments, while typically small, can add up over time, so it’s worth factoring them into your overall cost of joining.

Reputation is another critical factor. While a SACCO may be licensed and compliant with SASRA, it’s still important to gauge its reputation in the marketplace. Word-of-mouth recommendations, member testimonials, and online reviews can provide valuable insights into a SACCO’s customer service quality and overall member satisfaction. If a SACCO has a poor reputation for delayed payments, lack of transparency, or a history of mismanagement, then no matter how attractive its returns may seem, it’s likely to be a risky investment.

Therefore, investing in a SACCO can be a smart move for those seeking to grow their savings, access affordable loans, and gain a stake in a member-driven financial institution. However, as with any investment, it’s essential to do your due diligence before committing your hard-earned cash. Don’t be swayed by the promise of high dividends alone—take a comprehensive look at the SACCO’s financial stability, governance, loan offerings, accessibility, and overall reputation. By doing so, you’ll be well-equipped to make an informed decision that aligns with your financial goals, and most importantly, protects your savings. Remember, the right SACCO is not just one that offers the best returns but one that can deliver those returns reliably and safely over the long term.

Related Content: What Every Kenyan Should Know Before Joining A SACCO: Risks, Rewards, And Realities