Magnetic Materials That Could Replace Rare Earths In EV Motors

Rare earth magnets are a crucial component of electric motors in an electric vehicle (EV). According to IDTechEx, rare earth permanent magnet motors have retained a greater than 75% market share since 2015 thanks to their efficiency, power density, and manufacturing simplicity.
Many will be aware of the concerns around rare earth materials, such as price volatility and environmental impact. Another is China’s dominance in its supply of processed materials. Much focus is placed on the battery supply and localization of production (and rightly so), but motor components are also critical.
One way to alleviate concerns is by adopting magnetic materials that do not contain rare earths. Based on IDTechEx’s latest research report on “Electric Motors for Electric Vehicles 2025-2035: Technologies, Materials, Markets, and Forecasts”, this article will cover some of the most promising alternatives and their trade-offs.
Key metrics for magnetic materials
- A stronger magnet means a smaller, more efficient electric motor. Key properties of any magnetic material include:
- Maximum energy product (how much magnetic energy is stored)
- Magnetic remanence (magnetic intensity after the magnetizing field is removed)
- Coercivity (ability to resist demagnetization)
Ideally, these properties should be as high as possible. The most common form of rare earth magnet is neodymium iron boron (NdFeB). These possess strong performance in all three.
The alternatives
- While there are many other magnetic materials, none can currently compete with NdFeB on all three metrics.
- Aluminum nickel cobalt (AlNiCo) magnets have strong remanence, but poor coercivity and maximum energy product. Cobalt is also an expensive and somewhat controversial material.
- Samarium cobalt (SmCo) magnets have comparable remanence and coercivity but poorer maximum energy products. Again, they contain cobalt which is not ideal.
- Manganese bismuth (MnBi) magnets lose much of their coercivity during manufacturing and the maximum energy product is still much lower than NdFeB.
- Ferrite magnets like iron nitride (FeN) typically fall short of NdFeB on all counts but are abundant and cheap. They also allow for higher temperature operation, meaning the performance gap could be closed slightly when operating with a hotter motor.
- Alternative magnetic materials can often compete on certain magnetic parameters, but generally not all of them. Source: IDTechEx
What has to be changed in the motor?
The most immediate change is the size of the magnets. Due to their poorer magnetic performance, the magnets need to be larger. A typical rare earth motor will use 1-2kg of magnets, for a ferrite motor, this figure would likely double or even triple. This creates a challenge in the rotor’s structural integrity as the magnets will make up a much larger proportion of the rotor, rather than the electrical steel.
Even with larger magnets, the performance of the motor would be very challenging to compare to rare earth motors, resulting in a larger or lower power motor. Rare earth magnets make up a large portion of a motor’s bill of materials (up to 50%, according to IDTechEx research). This might not be such a large concern for specific lower-performance use cases, and the material savings could outweigh the performance hit.
While other magnets can operate at higher temperatures without demagnetization, this might be a hard benefit to realize. As temperature increases the resistance in the conductors will also increase, reducing efficiency.
Players looking at alternative magnets for EV motors
Given the potential benefits of eliminating rare earths, several projects and companies are looking to provide solutions; a few examples are given below.
Niron – iron nitride magnets with field strength approaching NdFeB. It has investors including Volvo, Stellantis, and GM.
Proterial – previously Hitachi Metals, has publicized the use of NMF15 (ferrite magnets) that provide the world’s highest performance for ferrites.
PASSENGER (Pilot Action for Securing a Sustainable European Next Generation of Efficient RE-free Magnets) – an EU project to develop improved strontium-ferrite, and manganese-aluminum-carbon alloys to enable permanent magnet production in Europe.
Could recycled magnets be a better alternative?
Given the limitations of alternative magnetic materials, one could consider using recycled magnets from end-of-life products. One key challenge is material supply. It will take a long time for enough EVs to reach their end-of-life to make a dent in the required materials for new EVs. There is also the challenge of recovering these materials given most electric motors are not designed for easy disassembly. Nonetheless, there are projects from players like Polestar, Advanced Electric Machines, Nissan, and other government projects looking to improve the recycling of rare earths. In the long term, the cost, efficiency, and feedstock for recycled rare earths could be suitable, but this is certainly not a short term solution to supplying the current demand.
Outlook for alternative magnetic materials
Despite the challenges, due to the uncertainty around material pricing and a general global drive to secure supply chains locally, IDTechEx is predicting growth in the EV market that uses rare earth-free magnets. If magnet-free motors (such as externally excited synchronous motors, EESMs) are included, then IDTechEx predicts that nearly 30% of the EV market will be using rare earth-free motors by 2035.
Read Also: The Surge Of Electric And Hybrid Cars In Kenya
By Dr James Edmondson, Research Director
About Soko Directory Team
Soko Directory is a Financial and Markets digital portal that tracks brands, listed firms on the NSE, SMEs and trend setters in the markets eco-system. Find us on Facebook: facebook.com/SokoDirectory and on Twitter: twitter.com/SokoDirectory
- January 2025 (118)
- February 2025 (74)
- January 2024 (238)
- February 2024 (227)
- March 2024 (190)
- April 2024 (133)
- May 2024 (157)
- June 2024 (145)
- July 2024 (136)
- August 2024 (154)
- September 2024 (212)
- October 2024 (255)
- November 2024 (196)
- December 2024 (143)
- January 2023 (182)
- February 2023 (203)
- March 2023 (322)
- April 2023 (298)
- May 2023 (268)
- June 2023 (214)
- July 2023 (212)
- August 2023 (257)
- September 2023 (237)
- October 2023 (264)
- November 2023 (286)
- December 2023 (177)
- January 2022 (293)
- February 2022 (329)
- March 2022 (358)
- April 2022 (292)
- May 2022 (271)
- June 2022 (232)
- July 2022 (278)
- August 2022 (253)
- September 2022 (246)
- October 2022 (196)
- November 2022 (232)
- December 2022 (167)
- January 2021 (182)
- February 2021 (227)
- March 2021 (325)
- April 2021 (259)
- May 2021 (285)
- June 2021 (272)
- July 2021 (277)
- August 2021 (232)
- September 2021 (271)
- October 2021 (304)
- November 2021 (364)
- December 2021 (249)
- January 2020 (272)
- February 2020 (310)
- March 2020 (390)
- April 2020 (321)
- May 2020 (335)
- June 2020 (327)
- July 2020 (333)
- August 2020 (276)
- September 2020 (214)
- October 2020 (233)
- November 2020 (242)
- December 2020 (187)
- January 2019 (251)
- February 2019 (215)
- March 2019 (283)
- April 2019 (254)
- May 2019 (269)
- June 2019 (249)
- July 2019 (335)
- August 2019 (293)
- September 2019 (306)
- October 2019 (313)
- November 2019 (362)
- December 2019 (318)
- January 2018 (291)
- February 2018 (213)
- March 2018 (275)
- April 2018 (223)
- May 2018 (235)
- June 2018 (176)
- July 2018 (256)
- August 2018 (247)
- September 2018 (255)
- October 2018 (282)
- November 2018 (282)
- December 2018 (184)
- January 2017 (183)
- February 2017 (194)
- March 2017 (207)
- April 2017 (104)
- May 2017 (169)
- June 2017 (205)
- July 2017 (189)
- August 2017 (195)
- September 2017 (186)
- October 2017 (235)
- November 2017 (253)
- December 2017 (266)
- January 2016 (164)
- February 2016 (165)
- March 2016 (189)
- April 2016 (143)
- May 2016 (245)
- June 2016 (182)
- July 2016 (271)
- August 2016 (247)
- September 2016 (233)
- October 2016 (191)
- November 2016 (243)
- December 2016 (153)
- January 2015 (1)
- February 2015 (4)
- March 2015 (164)
- April 2015 (107)
- May 2015 (116)
- June 2015 (119)
- July 2015 (145)
- August 2015 (157)
- September 2015 (186)
- October 2015 (169)
- November 2015 (173)
- December 2015 (205)
- March 2014 (2)
- March 2013 (10)
- June 2013 (1)
- March 2012 (7)
- April 2012 (15)
- May 2012 (1)
- July 2012 (1)
- August 2012 (4)
- October 2012 (2)
- November 2012 (2)
- December 2012 (1)